York Insurance of Maine, Inc. v. Superintendent of Insurance

[¶ 1] The Superintendent of the Bureau of Insurance appeals from a decision of the Superior Court (Cumberland County, Croivley, J.), vacating decisions of the Superintendent in two appeals of nonrenewal of homeowner’s insurance policies. In each case, York Insurance of Maine had declined to renew a homeowner’s policy because the policyholders operated a daycare business at their home, even though each policyholder had a separate commercial liability policy covering the daycare business. After a hearing, the Superintendent found that York had not met its burden of proving that the reasons for *1157n…