Legal Opinion · Dissent

Scroggins v. Corning Glass Company

Michigan Court of Appeals

Decided July 24, 1968No. Docket 1,544Published

1DissentHolbrook, P. J.

My brother judges quote 1 Larson, Workmen’s Compensation Law, § 13.21, p 192.86, as supporting their position. The cases cited in Larson are distinguishable on their facts from the case at hand. In the most favorable case cited therein, Fennell v. Maryland Casualty Company (1961), 208 Tenn 116 (344 SW2d 352), the employee suffered pain following a back injury and operation. When the drugs prescribed by his doctor were exhausted he substituted whisky in nonintoxicating doses to ease the pain. Compensation was awarded when the development of acute hepatitis in addition to malnutrition, the…

2Cases cited3 opinions

  1. Pigue v. General Motors Corp.Michigan Supreme Court · 1947
  2. Garrett v. Chrysler CorporationMichigan Supreme Court · 1953
  3. Fennell v. Maryland Casualty Co.Tennessee Supreme Court · 1961

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API