Hylton v. Hamilton

By Judge Edward L. Hogshire

In this civil action, Matthew Hamilton has filed a motion in limine to exclude evidence of another rape allegation at trial. Briefs were submitted on the matter and an oral hearing was held on July 7, 2005. The Court granted a protective order to conceal the identity of the third party, and requested that counsel file the deposition of Jane Roe (“Witness”) with the Court under seal. Having reviewed the deposition, other relevant exhibits, applicable law, and the arguments of both parties, the Court grants Defendant’s motion.

*306 Statement of Facts

In December 2001, while…