City of Jackson v. McLeod

Concurring Opinion.

'Sydney Smith, G. J.,

delivered a concurring opinion.

I am of the opinion that the Court below should have granted the appellant’s request for a directed verdict. I regret that I am unable to concur in the reasons therefor that influenced Judges L. A. Smith, Alexander and Griffith, as set forth in Judge .Griffith’s opinion, thereby preventing the decision here made from being an authoritative precedent in cases arising under Chapter 208-, Laws of 1944.

The question presented to the Court below was not “whether the- action, taken by the Civil Service Commission was in good…