Legal Opinion

Pumphrey v. Empire Lath and Plaster

Montana Supreme Court

Decided May 9, 2006No. 05-323PublishedCited by 13 opinions

1Opinion of the CourtJustice Leaphart

¶1 Lisa Pumphrey (Pumphrey) sued Rick Lee Pagitt and Empire *118Lath and Plaster (collectively, Empire) for negligence. A jury awarded Pumphrey $3.9 million. Empire now appeals. We affirm.

¶2 The dispositive issues on appeal are:

¶3 (1) whether the District Court erred in denying Empire’s motion for an independent medical examination pursuant to Rule 35, M.R.Civ.P.; and

¶4 (2) whether the District Court had authority to reconvene and re-poll the jury after discharging the jurors.

FACTUAL AND PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND

¶5 This cause of action arose out of an automobile accident, wherein Pagitt, while in the…

2Cases cited27 opinions

  1. Henricksen v. StateMontana Supreme Court · 2004
  2. McKenzie v. ScheelerMontana Supreme Court · 1997
  3. Chase v. Bearpaw Ranch Ass'nMontana Supreme Court · 2006
  4. Gaustad ex rel. M.G. v. City of ColumbusMontana Supreme Court · 1994
  5. McDermott v. CARIE, LLCMontana Supreme Court · 2005

22 more not listed; retrieve them via the Exa API.

3Cited by13 opinions

  1. Bitterroot International Systems, Ltd. v. Western Star Trucks, Inc.Montana Supreme Court · 2007
  2. Beehive Homes v. HardingMontana Supreme Court · 2006
  3. Pumphrey v. Empire Lath & PlasterMontana Supreme Court · 2006
  4. State v. Donald P. RogersMontana Supreme Court · 2013
  5. State v. E. YeatonMontana Supreme Court · 2021

8 more not listed; retrieve them via the Exa API.

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API