Estate of Silverman v. Manufacturers Hanover Trust Co.

The remedy of summary judgment in lieu of a complaint, as provided for in CPLB. 3213, is available only in an action “ based upon a judgment or instrument for the payment of money only”. The instant action, to recover moneys alleged to have been paid out improperly by defendant bank upon a check issued by plaintiffs’ decedent, does not come within either of these categories.

The orders should be unanimously modified by providing that the denial of the motions for summary judgment is without prejudice to renewal after joinder of issue upon formal pleadings, and as so modified, affirmed, without…