McEnany v. Ryan

Petitioner, Shane P. McEnany, the defendant in a personal injury action, seeks certiorari review of two non-final orders of the trial court which denied his objections to the personal injury plaintiffs motion to compel production of his medical records. We grant the petition, as no nexus between the accident and most of petitioner’s medical records was shown, yet the court failed to conduct an in camera inspection of the records.

Respondent, Robert Ryan, filed an action for negligence against petitioner as a result of an automobile accident. Petitioner filed a counterclaim for personal injury…