McClarren v. Buck

This is an appeal, by. plaintiffs from judgments of no cause of action. The basis of the appeal is the following instructions given to the jury:

“I charge you that merely because .an accident happens and an injury results does not in and of itself give rise to the fact that it is necessary to bring a verdict in favor of the plaintiffs in thesé cases. I charged you before along that line that the mere happening of an. accident doesn’t in and of itself warrant a verdict in favor, .of .the plaintiffs.

“In that connection, I charge yon that should you find from the facts and circumstances that this…