Legal Opinion · Dissent

Richards v. Smith

Court of Appeals of Texas

Decided April 27, 1951No. 15236Published

1DissentHall, Justice

The writer respectfully submits the following views and reasons for dissenting from the majority opinion:

*7281. The trial court by its action in sustaining appellee’s motion for summary judgment found as a matter of law that appellant failed to establish a fact issue.

2. There is no question but that appellant established a fact issue as to whether he had a meritorious defense to the original suit.

3. One of the few grounds for setting a final judgment aside is that the movant must prove he was prevented from making a valid defense to the original cause of action by extrinsic fraud, accident or…

2Cases cited4 opinions

  1. Alexander v. HagedornTexas Supreme Court · 1950
  2. Garcia v. RamosCourt of Appeals of Texas · 1948
  3. Buratti & Montandon v. TennantTexas Supreme Court · 1949
  4. Cotten v. StanfordCourt of Appeals of Texas · 1943

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API