Sheffield v. Superior Insurance Co.

BROWNING, J„

dissenting.

I respectfully dissent.

I

There was substantial and uncontrovert-ed evidence presented in this case that the appellant, Mary Ann Sheffield (Sheffield), sustained a permanent injury as a result of the accident. Three (3) physicians, Dr. Lopez, Dr. Rigoberto Puente-Guzman,7 and Dr. Bruce Richards, testified that Sheffield sustained a permanent injury, and no expert testified in opposition. Of particular significance is that the physician retained by Superior Insurance (Superior), Dr. Bruce Richards, to perform an independent medical evaluation of Sheffield, testified that…