Ratner v. Drucker

The basic question upon’ this application is whether the rendition of normal medical services by a licensed physician constitutes a consumer credit transaction.

The action is for. a balance due for medical services rendered to one Harry Drucker, now deceased, by plaintiff doctor. The motion is by defendant wife administratrix of the estate of Harry Drucker and ,by said defendant individually to dismiss the action,. pursuant to CPLR .3211 and subdivision (d) of section 401 of the CCA, for failure to serve a proper summons which is printed legibly in both English and Spanish.

Defendants’ claim is…