O'Boyle v. Carteret Ferry Corp.

AUGUSTUS N. HAND, Circuit Judge.

No attempt is made to review the decision of the District Court that all three of the colliding vessels were at fault and, upon the merits, equally responsible for the damages resulting from the collision. This appeal presents only the question of the extent of the liability of the Red Ash, and her stipula-tors for value, because of the fact that no claim has been asserted against the Red Ash. except for the damage to the Asfalto.

The owner of the barge Asfalto libeled the John Englis and the Red Ash, alleging damage “in the making of repairs, towing, survey…