Selwyn A. Robinson, Trustee Under the Will of Alymer F. Robinson Eleanor Robinson, Trustee Under the Will of Aylmer F. Robinson Bruce R. Robinson, Trustee Under the Will of Aylmer F. Robinson Russell S. Robinson Helen M. Robinson, Individually and as of the Estate of Lester B. Robinson Ruth R. Le Fiell Marion R. Keat Jean R. Weir Keith P. Y v. George R. Ariyoshi, Governor Ronald Y. Amemiya, Attorney General Andrew S.O. Lee William Y. Thompson Stanley W. Hong Larry E. Mehau Manuel Moniz, Jr. Moses W. Kealoha Takeo Yamamoto, Chairman and Members, Board of Land and Natural Resources, State of Hawaii, as Succeeded by John D. Waihee, Governor, State of Hawaii, Warren Price, Iii, Attorney General, State of Hawaii, William W. Paty, John Y. Arisumi, Herbert Y. Arata, J. Douglas Ing, Moses W. Kealoha and Leonard H. Zalopany, Chairman and Members, Board of Land and Natural Resources, State of Hawaii v. McBryde Sugar Company, Ltd., Olokele Sugar Company, Ltd. Ida Albarado Helen B. Chu Henry J. Chu Chee Kung Fui Society Lapaz Francisco Marcelino Francisco Albert K. Kaailua Linda P. Kaiakapu Ann N. Kali Harriet U. Kano Junichi Kano Kiyoshi Kimata Arnold W.F. Leong Katherine A. Leong Lo Sun D. Leong Tai Hung Leong Hanayo T. Naumu Wallace A. Naumu Hideo Nonaka Hiromi Nonaka Kazuo Nonaka Masatoshi Nonaka Shigekichi Nonaka Takano Nonaka and Tadao Nonaka, (Two Cases)

Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit