Exxon Mobil Corp. v. Ford

I concur, in part, with Judge Robert A. Zarnoch’s opinion and, in part, with Judge James R. Eyler’s opinion.

Property Value

As to the issue of whether there was sufficient evidence to uphold the jury’s verdict that all of appellees’ properties were worthless or could not be sold, I would affirm the jury’s award of property damages to those homeowners who “either explic*248itly or implicitly” testified that they believed their homes retained no market value for the reasons stated below.

I agree with Judge Zamoch’s assessment that twenty-six homeowners “either explicitly or implicitly” testified that…