Carpenelli v. Scranton Bus Co.

Dissenting Opinion by

Mr. Justice Deew :

After reading this record, I cannot concur in the conclusion which the majority has reached. In view of the very serious and permanent nature of plaintiff’s injuries, his great expense for hospital and medical attendance, the pain and suffering which he has and will endure as a result of the negligence of defendant, and his loss of past and future earnings, I am convinced that the verdict is, as was said in Palmer v. The Leader Publishing Co., 75 Pa. Superior Ct. 594, 598, so unreasonable as to bring conviction “the jury must have been influenced by…