QHG of Springdale, Inc. v. Archer

The majority begins its opinion with a proverb about the need for a yoke of oxen to pull a piece of paper out of a court. Yet, the only ones that might use that yoke are the members of the majority. The jury was able to listen to the evidence, deliberate, and reach a verdict. This verdict was supported by the evidence presented, and there is absolutely no reason for this court to remand this case for trial before a second jury. Therefore, I must respectfully dissent.

I begin with what is noticeably absent from the majority’s opinion: a discussion of this court’s standard of review. QHG appeals…