American Investors Life Insurance v. TCB Transportation, Inc.

“Good results make bad law.” It is a statement I have heard time and time again in my experiences as an appellate judge. The majority opinion issued today lends truth to the statement, so much so that it compels me to dissent.

Consistently with other results-oriented opinions of this court, the majority opinion issued today jumps to an unfounded conclusion. In this particular case, that unfounded conclusion is that appellee Steve Turner does not have an adequate remedy at law. There is absolutely nothing in the record that can be used to support this conclusion. The conclusion requires…