Phillips v. Phillips

(dissenting)- — When this case was first heard in Department, it was assigned to the late Judge Fullerton for opinion, and he prepared that which is hereinafter quoted, which failed of majority support. In my judgment, the views expressed by Judge Fullerton are sound, just and equitable, and should prevail for the reasons stated by him.

And in addition thereto, I may say that the allowance to the respondent was specifically made for the support of herself and the minor daughter, and was strictly limited to the period which would expire one year after the daughter reached the age of twenty-one…