Legal Opinion
Scherr Manufacturing Co. v. American Union Fire Insurance
Louisiana Court of Appeal
Decided February 25, 1914No. 5981Published
Appeal from the Civil District Court, for the Parish of Orleans, Division “D,” No. 103,841. Hon. Porter Parker, Judge.
1Opinion of the Court
His Honor, EMILE GODCHAUX,
rendered the opinion and decree of the Court, as follows:
In Bottazzi vs. American Union Fire Insurance Company, No. 5982, of our docket, this day decided, we held:
“An appeal from a judgment in plaintiff’s favor against defendant, upon the main demand, does not constitute an appeal from a separate and distinct judgment, rendered prior thereto, dismissing an intervention.
“The correctness of a judgment upon a main demand from which third persons appeal must be tested *132upon the facts pleaded and proved prior to its rendition and cannot be made to hinge upon an allegation,…
2Cases cited3 opinions
- St. Clair v. CoxSupreme Court of the United States · 1882
- Baham v. Stewart Bros. & Co.Supreme Court of Louisiana · 1903
- Curtis v. JordanSupreme Court of Louisiana · 1905