50 State Security Service, Inc. v. Giangrandi

The record reflects that the trial court erred by: (1) repeatedly and materially restricting the ability of 50 State Security Service, Inc. (“50 State Security”) to present its defense; and (2) denying 50 State Security’s motion for a directed verdict and subsequent motion for a new trial where the plaintiff failed to prove either a breach of 50 State Security’s duty or causation. I, therefore, respectfully dissent.

Lidia Giangrandi was murdered in her home by Rafael Matarranz (“Matarranz”). Ms. Giangrandi’s home was located in the community of Loch Lomond, a special taxing district protected…