NYC C.L.A.S.H. v. City of New York

OPINION OF THE COURT

Frank P. Ñervo, J.

Motion sequence Nos. 001 and 002 are combined for disposition in the following decision and order.

In motion sequence No. 001, plaintiffs move for summary judgment declaring Local Law No. 152 (2013) of City of New York § 1 et seq. (Local Law 152), unconstitutional as it violates the single subject rule contained in NY Constitution, article III, § 15, Municipal Home Rule Law § 20 (3) and New York City Charter § 32.

In motion sequence No. 002, defendants move to dismiss plaintiffs’ complaint.

The court has considered the affirmations in support of each motion,…