Legal Opinion · Dissent

Stauch Estate

Supreme Court of Pennsylvania

Decided March 16, 1973No. Appeal, No. 30Published

1Dissent

Dissenting Opinion by

Me. Justice Roberts:

I must dissent from the majority’s decision that the orphans’ court division was correct in holding, in 1971, that a fine, imposed in 1949 as part of a final judgment of sentence, abates upon the death of the defendant. The majority’s determination, in my view, suffers from two basic errors, one jurisdictional, the other substantive.

I

The majority, without specifically addressing the issue, concludes that the orphans’ court division has jurisdiction to vacate a final judgment of sentence, imposing a fine, of a court of oyer and terminer.1 The…

2Cases cited5 opinions

  1. Commonwealth v. WalkerSupreme Court of Pennsylvania · 1972
  2. Commonwealth (To Use, Ap.) v. EmbodySuperior Court of Pennsylvania · 1940
  3. Estate of McClainSupreme Court of Pennsylvania · 1897
  4. Estate of BlakeSupreme Court of Pennsylvania · 1890
  5. Schauble EstateSupreme Court of Pennsylvania · 1944

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API