Reynolds v. Rowley

The judgment of the court was pronounced by

Rost, J.

Our attempt, when this case was last before us (2 An. 890 ), to arrive at a final decision of it, by settling in advance the legal principles on which it turns, and remanding it to be tided before another jury on the issues of fact, has signally failed. An inquiry into the causes of that failure will make the errors of the last verdict apparent, and enable us to replace the parties in their true position towards each other.

We stated in the opinion then delivered, the probability of there being something due to the plaintiffs over and above…