Caulkins v. Crabtree

I dissent. Whether Mr. Caulkins was unavailable or whether the state made a diligent, good-faith effort to bring him to trial are dependent upon disputed facts. Caulkins testified he had moved, changed addresses, disconnected his phone and never told Arkansas authorities of these changes, even though he made two appearances in court in Arkansas after his move. Caulkins’ new residence was one with all utility bills paid. While he made the foregoing move and changes without telling Arkansas authorities, Caulkins claimed Texas authorities still could have determined his new address since he…