McKinley v. State Board of Funeral Directors

Concurring Opinion by

Judge Crumlish, Jr. :

While I concur in the result reached by the Court today, I disagree with the reasoning leading to it. As I said in my dissenting opinion in Manheim Township *48School District v. State Board of Education, 1 Pa. Commonwealth Ct. 627, 276 A. 2d 561 (1971),1 “I believe that Article Y, Section 9 [of the Pennsylvania Constitution] was not intended to limit its reference to appeals from ‘administrative’ agencies to ‘adjudications.’ ” (Emphasis in original) Therefore the finding that the letter which precipitated this appeal was not an “adjudication” within the…