Legal Opinion · Dissent

County of Cook v. Industrial Commission

Illinois Supreme Court

Decided October 5, 1977No. 48965Published

1DissentJustice Dooley

I would affirm the award of the Industrial Commission.

Dr. Savitt, in response to a hypothetical question, was asked “whether or not there might be a causal connection between either the lifting [of the 35-pound tract books] or the getting up from the desk and the pushing of the chair out from under the desk in the semi-stooped position” and the claimant’s accident. The doctor responded, “I think there might be a connection.” There was no objection to this testimony.

The majority, in treating this testimony, states: “In response to this multiple question, including the either/or disjunctive…

2Cases cited13 opinions

  1. The People v. TrefonasIllinois Supreme Court · 1956
  2. Wirth v. Industrial CommissionIllinois Supreme Court · 1974
  3. Illinois Valley Irrigation, Inc. v. Industrial CommissionIllinois Supreme Court · 1977
  4. Ascher Bros. Amusement Enterprises v. Industrial CommissionIllinois Supreme Court · 1924
  5. Atlantic & Pacific Tea Co. v. Industrial CommissionIllinois Supreme Court · 1977

8 more not listed; retrieve them via the Exa API.

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API