Bourne v. Bourne

I regret most sincerely my inability to

secure the approval of my own conscience, which is absolutely necessary, in order to agree with my sincere, able, and distinguished associates in their conclusion as expressed in the foregoing opinion. I therefore dissent.

In view of what appears to me the importance of this case, coupled with the fact that this presents our first disagreement, I submit the case as I see it, rather than, as is customary, to discuss only the points upon which we disagree:

Plaintiff, in her amended complaint, alleges the activity of both defendants—her husband’s father and…