Elwood Construction Co. Ex Rel. Elrod v. Richards

(dissenting) :

I most respectfully dissent. There is, in my view, an absence of any clear preponderance of evidence which would warrant this Court in reversing the concurrent findings of the master and circuit judge. The record abundantly supports their concurrent findings that there was insufficient -probative evidence on which to base any specific findings of fact as to the acreage involved in the respective areas.

There is no doubt about the competence of Mr. Gaillard, and I question none of his testimony, but when considered *235in its entirety, it leaves the acreage involved in each of the…