Associated Builders and Contractors, Inc., Golden Gate Chapter Golden Gate Chapter Associated Builders and Contractors Training Trust Fund Golden Gate Chapter of Associated Builders and Contractors Bat Training Program v. James Curry and Ronald T. Rinaldi, in Their Official Capacities as Labor Commissioner of the State of California, and Director of Industrial Relations for the State of California, and Operating Engineers Joint Apprenticeship Committee Carpenters 46 Northern California Counties Joint Apprenticeship and Training Committee Northern California Cement Masons Joint Apprenticeship and Training Committee California & Vicinity Field Iron Workers Joint Apprenticeship Committee, Intervenors-Appellees. Walther Electric Company Walther Electric Company Training Committee v. James Curry and Ronald T. Rinaldi, in Their Official Capacities as Labor Commissioner of the State of California, and Director of Industrial Relations for the State of California, and Operating Engineers Joint Apprenticeship Committee Carpenters 46 Northern California Counties Joint Apprenticeship and Training Committee Northern California Cement Masons Joint Apprenticeship and Training Committee California & Vicinity Field Iron Workers Joint Apprenticeship Committee, Intervenors-Appellees

Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit