Smith v. Graf

Opinion of the -Court by

Drury, Commissioner

Affirming.

On 'August 23, 1926, R. J. Graf and Beaver Creek Consolidated Coal Company sued Adam Smith et al., to quiet their title to the olil and gas under and appurtenant to two tracts of land. They were successful, and Smith et al. have appealed.

On November 22, 1926, the same plaintiffs filed a similar suit against Eliza Cox et al. relative to another tract, they were again successful, and Eliza Cox et al. have appealed.

In each of these petitions the plaintiffs alleged that the Beaver Creek Consolidated Coal Company owned one-eighth, and that R. J.…