Parrish v. MacHlan

Marianna Brown Bettman, Judge.

Plaintiff-appellee, Carole Parrish, sought the services of defendant-appellant, John Machlan, a bench jeweler 1 with defendant Goldsmith’s Hall, Inc., to redesign a ring she had inherited from her grandmother. The ring was made up of diamonds and sapphires. When the redesigned ring was finished, both the new ring and a number of unused loose stones from the original ring were returned to Parrish'. Parrish claimed that one diamond was missing, that two of the diamonds, one of which was synthetic, were not part of the original set, and that several remaining stones…