Mullins v. State

James P. Mullins appeals his convictions for manslaughter and two counts of culpable negligence resulting in personal injury, arguing that improper comments during closing argument compel reversal. We agree and reverse.

Evidence at Trial

Anthony Gehle died as the result of an automobile collision that immediately followed an altercation between him and the defendant. Gehle’s daughter and sister-in-law were also in the car and sustained injuries in the crash. Gehle’s death and the injuries sustained by the daughter and the sister-in-law gave rise to criminal charges against the defendant.

Evidence…