Hirsch v. Optima, Inc.

THIRD DIVISION December 9, 2009 Nos. 1-08-1347 & 1-08-1378 (consolidated) JUDITH HIRSCH, ) Appeal from the Circuit ) Court of Cook County, Illinois Plaintiff-Appellee and Cross-Appellant, ) ) No. 05 CH 6841 v. ) ) Honorable Martin Agran, OPTIMA, INC., an Illinois Corporation, ) Judge Presiding ) Defendant-Appellant and Cross-Appellee ) ) (John H. Kelsey and Coromandel Town Home ) Association, ) ) Defendants). ) PRESIDING JUSTICE MURPHY delivered the opinion of the court: After plaintiff, Judith Hirsch, purchased a townhouse from defendant John Kelsey in 2002, the basement flooded. On April…