Payne v. City of Miami

I would grant rehearing en banc, withdraw the majority opinion, and affirm the order of the Department of Community Affairs which adopted the recommended order of the administrative law judge (ALJ), finding the small scale amendment at issue consistent with the Miami Comprehensive Neighborhood Plan. I would do so for the following reasons.

First, the opinion improperly reweighs the evidence in direct contravention of section 120.68(7)(b) of the Florida Statutes which, as pertinent here, expressly provides that although a court may set aside agency action when it finds that “agency action…