Smith v. Stilphen

Smith v . Stilphen CV-04-101-JD 11/17/04 P UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF NEW HAMPSHIRE Rhonda Smith and Mark Smith v. Civil N o . 04-101 JD Opinion N o .

2004 DNH 162

Janet G. Stilphen O R D E R Janet G. Stilphen has moved to dismiss the complaint of Rhonda and Mark Smith to the extent they seek to recover the earnings lost while caring for their son, Matthew, since he received permanent injuries in a collision between his bicycle and Stilphen’s van. Stilphen argues that, because Matthew was nineteen years old at the time he became disabled, his parents no longer had any duty…