Cocanougher v. Zeigler

Mr. Justice Morris:

I dissent. This is an equity case, and is governed by these long established rules:(1) The credibility of the witnesses and the weight of their testimony is exclusively for the trial court. (Bowen v. Webb, 37 Mont. 479, 97 Pac. 839; Consolidated Gold & S. Min. Co. v. Struthers, 41 Mont. 551, 111 Pac. 150; Blinn v. Hutterische Soc., 58 Mont. 542, 194 Pac. 140; Orton v. Bender, 43 Mont. 263, 115 Pac. 406; Parchen v. Chessman, 53 Mont. 430, 164 Pac. 531; Dockins v. Dockins, 82 Mont. 218, 266 Pac. 398; Piersky v. Hocking, 88 Mont. 358, 292 Pac. 725; Wallace v. Wallace, 85 Mont.…