Shapiro v. VPA, P.C. (In Re Valley X-Ray Co.)

OPINION AND ORDER AFFIRMING GRANT OF SUMMARY JUDGMENT

JOHN FEIKENS, District Judge.

The Chapter 7 Trustee of Valley X-Ray Company (Appellant) 1 commenced an adversarial proceeding against VPA, P.C. (Appellee), seeking to force Appellee to disgorge money it obtained through a transaction Appellant claims was a fraudulent conveyance. Bankruptcy Judge Tucker granted summary judgment for Appel-lee, finding that Appellee was not a party that could be forced to disgorge money in this matter. Appellant appeals this ruling. I hereby AFFIRM Bankruptcy Judge Tucker’s decision.

I. FACTUAL BACKGROUND

Valley…