Legal Opinion · Dissent

Hart v. Larkin

West Virginia Supreme Court

Decided November 16, 1909Published

Appeal from Circuit Court, Kandolph County. Bill by Fenner F. Hart against George A. Larkin, trustee, and others, to enjoin a sale under a deed of trust. Decree for defendants and complainant appeals.

1DissentBrannon, Judge

Were it the case of a deed of trust for an ordinary debt, I would have no question; but it is purchase money. When a conveyance is made, and at the same time, as part of the transaction, a deed of trust for purchase money is given, it is the same as the reservation of a lien in the conveyance. Roush v. Miller, 39 W. Va. 638. As there said, it is only another mode of retaining a lien. Indeed, I may say it is more forceful, because it is an agreement to sell for the lien, a pledge. Here is a covenant of general warranty, not broken by the existence of incumbrances. Our cases settle that in a…

2Cases cited8 opinions

  1. Kinports v. RawsonWest Virginia Supreme Court · 1887
  2. Neeley v. RuleysWest Virginia Supreme Court · 1885
  3. Roush v. MillerWest Virginia Supreme Court · 1894
  4. Bennett v. PierceWest Virginia Supreme Court · 1898
  5. Cain v. FisherWest Virginia Supreme Court · 1905

3 more not listed; retrieve them via the Exa API.

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API