Legal Opinion · Concurrence

Souza v. Sociedade De Sao Martinho Beneficente De Hawaii

Hawaii Supreme Court

Decided January 30, 1919No. 1139Published

Submission Upon Agreed Statement op Facts.

1Concurrence

CONCURRING OPINION OF

COKE, C. J.

I am in accord with the conclusion reached in the majority opinion. I base my concurrence, however, solely upon the effect of Act 47 S. L. 1915, which I think necessarily confines adoption proceedings in this Territory to minors. The opinion herein overruled Souza v. Lusitana Society, 24 Haw. 396. The error there would not have occurred but for the failure of counsel to call to the attention of the court the existence of Act 47 S. L. 1915, by virtue of which section 2994 R. L. 1915 was repealed.

2Cases cited1 opinion

  1. Souza v. Sociedade Lusitana Beneficente De HawaiiHawaii Supreme Court · 1918