Legal Opinion · Concurrence

Lyon & Healy v. Piano, Organ & Musical Instrument Workers' International Union

Illinois Supreme Court

Decided June 18, 1919No. 12451Published

Appeal from the Circuit Court of Cook county; the Hon. Frederick A. Smith, Judge, presiding.,

1Concurrence

Carter and Stone, JJ.,

specially concurring:

Under repeated decisions of this court on similar, if not identical, questions raised here, we'think the judgment of the lower court on this, a collateral attack, must be affirmed. We reach this conclusion with reluctance, because we are firmly convinced that the injunction order entered was entirely too sweeping in its provisions, particularly the provision enjoining the appellants, or those associating'with them, from interfering or attempting to hinder the appellee froih carrying on its business in the usual and ordinary way. It is difficult to…

2Cases cited3 opinions

  1. Kemp v. Division No. 241, Amalgamated Ass'n of Street & Electric Railway Employees of AmericaIllinois Supreme Court · 1912
  2. A. R. Barnes & Co. v. Chicago Typographical Union No. 16Illinois Supreme Court · 1908
  3. Illinois Malleable Iron Co v. MichalekIllinois Supreme Court · 1917

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API