Gardner v. International Shoe Co.

I am not in harmony with the majority opinion in this case, and, therefore, I feel called upon to dissent from said opinion.

In the majority opinion much time is given to the question of whether the verdicts are warranted by the evidence. To me that question is not now of importance. All such questions were submitted to the jury on enough evidence, it seems to me, to warrant the case going to the jury, and, therefore, those questions are decided and leave nothing but the one question as to whether the plaintiffs in these cases had a legal cause of action. We are all agreed that there is no…