Navistar, Inc. v. New Baltimore Garage, Inc.

McCULLOUGH, Judge.

The Commissioner of the Department of Motor Vehicles concluded that a chargeback in the amount of $57,333.60 and a reduction in the hourly labor rate that Navistar, Inc. imposed on New Baltimore Garage, Inc. for warranty work were invalid under Code § 46.2-1571. The Circuit Court for Fauquier County affirmed the Commissioner’s decision. Navistar appeals, challenging the Commissioner’s interpretation of the statute, as well as the evidence New Baltimore relied upon to establish a violation of Code § 46.2-1571. We conclude that the Commissioner erred in his interpretation of…