Lucas v. Board of Commissioners

Buskirk and Pettit, JJ.,

being unable to concur in the opinion and judgment pronounced by a majority- of the court, dissent therefrom and state the following reasons for their dissent:

The facts of the case and the questions of -law arising in the record sufficiently appear in the opinion of the majority of the court, and need not be re-stated. The cause was tried before Judge Vinton, who delivered a very able and exhaustive opinion in reference to the constitutionality of the law in question. We fully concur in the views expressed by the learned judge, and make his opinion a part of this…