Yates v. Mancari

I agree with the holding of this Court that the evidence in this case at least presented an issue for jury determination but firmly disagree with the Court’s holding that the trial court committed reversible error in giving to the *372jury plaintiffs’ Instructions 1, 3, 5, 6, 7 and 12. The female plaintiff will sometimes be referred to herein as plaintiff and the female defendant as defendant.

Although it will not be possible to discuss separately what I consider the several errors committed by the majority, they are substantially as follows: (1) the phrase “the evidence” in Instructions 5 and 7…