City of St. Augustine v. Graubard

SHARP, W., J.,

dissenting.

I respectfully dissent, because in my view, the circuit court failed to apply the correct law. Instead of determining whether the City’s zoning decision was supported by competent substantial evidence, the court granted the petition for certiorari based on conflicting evidence presented by Graubard, the property owner. On appeal; the City of St. Augustine, Florida, seeks review of the circuit court’s order granting Robert Graubard’s1 petition for certiorari, which quashed the City’s denial of Graubard’s rezoning application. I would reverse.

The record reflects that…