Hayes v. Relyea

We approve the lucid and comprehensive opinion and report of Dean Andrew V. Clements, Referee (43 Misc 2d 295), as confirmed at Special Term. Had the -decision adopted the alternative theory by following the strictly contractual approach, there would -be doubt whether plaintiffs established facts sufficient to entitle them to relief under the constitution of the international association (see, e.-g., art. D, § 12, thereof), but the question has not been raised and its determination is unnecessary in any event. Judgment and order affirmed, without costs. Gibson, P. J., Herlihy, Reynolds,…