Hall v. North Ogden City

I dissent. Material facts -which are the basis of my opinion were not disclosed in the prevailing opinion, and so a statement of facts is necessary: On October 16, 1869, the predecessors in interest of plaintiffs’ lands filed their claims thereto with the County judge under the Townsite Laws, and later made proof thereof and were adjudicated to be the owners and possessors of such lands, and received deeds through which plaintiffs derived their respective interests in such lands. The North Ogden Townsite had been previously entered in the Land Office by the County Judge of Weber County, it…