Treasure Craft Jewelers, Inc. v. Jefferson Insurance Company of New York

I must respectfully dissent from the majority’s affirmance of the district court’s order granting summary judgment in favor of the defendant Jefferson Insurance Company. The majority has concluded — as did the district court — that as a matter of law the plaintiff Treasure Craft’s insurance policy must be construed such that paragraph 7 of the policy (an insuring condition limiting coverage to the Levittown premises) controls to deny Treasure Craft coverage in this case, and that paragraph 2E as modified by an Endorsement (a limitation of liability limiting coverage to $25,000 for property…