Legal Opinion

Good v. Town of Chester

West Virginia Supreme Court

Decided January 19, 1909PublishedCited by 3 opinions

Error to Circuit Court, Hancock County. Action by Allie R. Good against the Town of Chester. Judgment for plaintiff., and defendant brings error.

1Opinion of the Court

Brannon, Judge:

Allie R. Good sued the town of Chester for damage done her lot from water and mud cast upon it from a street of the town, and recovered a verdict and judgment. The action was trespass on the case.

The record shows no plea of any kind, no issue joined. It shows that the jury were sworn. Sworn to do what? The record does not answer. It does not say the jury was sworn to try the issue. Had there been a plea and issue, that word “sworn” would have been sufficient?. But no plea or issue appears. It is very old law that there must be an-issue for a jury trial. That law seems to have…

2Cases cited3 opinions

  1. State v. DouglassWest Virginia Supreme Court · 1882
  2. Ruffner v. HillWest Virginia Supreme Court · 1882
  3. Stevens v. FriedmanWest Virginia Supreme Court · 1903

3Cited by3 opinions

  1. Hinkle v. North River Ins.West Virginia Supreme Court · 1912
  2. Security Bank Note Co. v. ShraderWest Virginia Supreme Court · 1912
  3. Shires v. BoggessWest Virginia Supreme Court · 1910

Showing a preview — retrieve the full document via the Exa API.

Powered by the Exa API