Andrews & Andrews v. Barton

This dispute, which returns to us for the second time, concerns the location of the border between two adjacent lots. Stewart and Leda Andrews own Lot 32 and Donald Barton owns Lot 31 of Block 54 on Stock Island in Monroe County, Florida. Previously, a jury had returned a verdict in favor of Barton and the Andrews appealed. Holding that certain evidence should not have been excluded from trial, we reversed and directed the trial court resolve the issue of the location of the lot boundaries. Andrews v. Barton, 974 So.2d 1144, 1147 (Fla. 3d DCA 2008).

On remand, the case was tried without a jury…